Commentary: I disagree with the Dropkick Murphys politics generally & with the jaundiced opinions expressed in "Worker's Song" specifically, but that is not to say they don't have a point, even in they express it with much the same lack of charity for which they indict their opponents. What's a week of songs about labor, in such close geographic proximity to the birthplace of the United Auto Workers, of which your humble narrator was once a member, without a little misguided blue-collar rage?
Of course, they contradict themselves, at one point singing:
"Yeah, this one's for the workers who toil night and day,But then later:
By hand and by brain to earn your pay…"
"In the factories and mills, in the shipyards and mines…"So, they praise workers who toil using their brains, but because that might include lawyers & investment bankers who toil for one hundred-plus hours a week, they then have to restrict "the workers who toil night & day" to a select few types of occupations. Not a word spared the toil necessary to generate the capital needed for those factories, mills, & shipyards to be build, for those mines to be dug. Only those who work in the proper twentieth century industrial occupations are true "workers." Socialist class-warfare claptrap, that.
No comments:
Post a Comment